Curious if premium hardware encoders are really worth the high price tag? We break down the features, costs, and performance of four popular encoders to see if spending over $2,500 actually gets you better results.
What’s an Encoder + Do You Need One?
What Do Video Encoders Typically Cost, Anyway?
Comparison of Video Encoder Feature Functionality
Final Thoughts
Live video streaming has been mainstream for nearly a decade. Periscope (remember that?) kicked things off in 2015, followed quickly by YouTube, Facebook, and Instagram in 2016. Even LinkedIn got in on the action by 2019.
Most social streaming today is done with a smartphone or laptop—and it's free. But just because it’s accessible doesn’t mean it’s simple. Behind the scenes there’s a lot of complex tech at play, and at the center of it all is encoding.
Video files are huge. Encoding compresses and converts that raw video into a format that can be streamed live over the internet. Whether you're using YouTube Live or running a full-blown multicam production with a digital mixer, the need is the same: turn raw audio and video into a smooth, low-latency stream that looks good and plays reliably on all kinds of devices and networks.
If you’re a church, school, or business, going live isn’t just about checking the box and being online. It’s a reflection on your brand, and communicates your message to your community. When it looks bad, people notice. Most general-purpose computers aren’t built to handle real-time video encoding consistently. They’re juggling other processes, and even powerful laptops can stumble under the pressure.
That’s why organizations looking to stream to their website, app, or social destinations turn to dedicated hardware encoders. These purpose-built devices are designed to do one thing really well: encode video for live streaming with stability, quality, and reliability.
But here’s the tricky part: there are a plethora of hardware encoders on the market and most of them have complicated names and are expensive. With this in mind, should a buyer assume that the more they spend, the better their stream will be? The job of this blog is to dig into whether such an assumption is actually true, or whether dropping $2,500+ on encoder hardware is more of a waste than an upgrade.
Entry-level video encoders start in the mid-hundreds, while top-tier options can carry a price tag of $10,000 or more. With hundreds of choices on the market, we’re focusing on four encoders that span the price spectrum, meet the standard requirements for professional streaming, and have seen broad adoption in the industry:
BoxCast Spark SDI – $1,299
Magewell Ultra Encode AIO – $3,000
Haivision Makito X4 – $6,000
Resi E4310 – $7,999
If you're evaluating a different encoder than the four listed above, we recommend looking up its tech specs online—you should be able to quickly and easily compare its functionality against the models we’ve selected here. But for now, these four suffice to make a strong case: when it comes to live streaming encoders, it’s not just about how much you spend, it’s about what you get for your investment.
In this comparison, we’re looking at criteria that fall into the following three key areas:
Flexibility – Options for internet connectivity, audio/video inputs, and customization
Quality – Max resolution, frame rate, and compression
Adaptability – Monitoring, adjustments, and general usability
| BoxCast Spark SDI | Magewell Ultra Encode AIO | Haivision Makito X4 | Resi E4310 | |
| Price | $1,299 | $3,000 | $6,000 | $7,999 |
| Video Input | 12G SDI | 6G SDI | 12G SDI | 12G SDI |
| Line In Audio | 3.5mm or ¼” | 3.5mm | ❌ | ❌ |
| Compression | HEVC H.265 | HEVC H.265 | HEVC H.265 | HEVC H.265 |
| Resolution | 1080p | 4K | 4K | 4K |
| Frame Rate | 60fps | 30fps | 60fps | 60fps |
| Touchscreen | 4.3" | ❌ | ❌ | ❌ |
| Local Recording | microSD | ❌ | ❌ | ❌ |
| Wi-Fi Option | ✅ | ❌ | ❌ | ❌ |
| Adjust Analog Audio | ✅ | ❌ | ❌ | ❌ |
| Speed Test | ✅ | ❌ | ❌ | ❌ |
| Live AV Monitoring | ✅ | ❌ | ❌ | ❌ |
Among the group, the Magewell Ultra Encode AIO 6G-SDI input supports lower bandwidth than the 12G-SDI connections found on the other encoders, and also lags behind at a maximum 30fps instead of 60fps. Meanwhile, the BoxCast Spark stands out as the only encoder limited to 1080p instead of 4K.
But what the Spark lacks in raw resolution, it makes up for everywhere else, scoring high in seven other categories. It offers both 3.5mm and ¼” analog audio inputs in addition to embedded audio, supports local recording via microSD, and includes both Wi-Fi and Ethernet connectivity. Its large touchscreen adds even more value, giving users on-device control over analog audio levels, as well as live audio and video monitoring, network speed tests, and more.
The biggest surprise, though, is that the encoder with the broadest set of features is also the most affordable. The BoxCast Spark SDI is $1,700 less than the next closest competitor, and a full $6,700 less than the most expensive option.
Despite its lower price point, the BoxCast Spark delivers a rare combination of flexibility, quality, and adaptability that is tough for the field to beat.
So, back to the question at hand: Are streaming hardware encoders over $2,500 really worth it? Based on what we’ve seen, the answer is pretty clear.
Encoders like the BoxCast Spark deliver a wide range of advanced, pro-level features—at nearly half the price. If you’ve been given a $2,500 budget for an encoder, going with the Spark not only gives you the best overall feature set, but leaves you with $1,201 to put toward other parts of your workflow.
That leftover budget could dramatically improve your setup with better microphones, upgraded monitors, improved cameras, or other gear to elevate your entire stream.
Finally, it’s worth noting that while the Spark's current output is capped at 1080p, it is capable of ingesting 4K video. Higher resolution streaming may become available in the future as technology advances and more devices are able to support 4K playback.
So, is a $2,500 encoder worth it? For us, the answer is no. Focus on the features that matter, not just the price tag, and allow the rest of your budget work harder for your overall live video streaming workflow.
Check out all that the BoxCast Spark live streaming hardware encoder has to offer.